Insure.com Car Insurance Review: Consumer Reviews, Quotes (2024)

If you’re taking your car insurance search online, you’re no doubt uncovering several new websites purporting to help you. And one you may have come across is Insure.com.

Insure.com is a lead-generation site that aims to simplify the insurance-buying process by breaking down pricing to help customers get the best rates. The site sets out to help users compare insurance policies from multiple insurance companies — then supplements this information with informative, up-to-date reviews from policyholders.

Find Cheap Car Insurance Near You

Check quotes from 100+ top insurance companies

Enter your ZIP codeView My Quotes

Secure. Free. Easy-to-use.

Based on 3,806+ reviews

4.8/5

Insure.com at a glance

Insure.com has been in business since 1999. The company is owned by the online marketing company Quinstreet. Both Insure.com and Quinstreet are based in San Mateo, California. Quinstreet maintains an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, though the company isn’t accredited.^[1]

Reviews through the BBB are few and sparse, but Quinstreet has a rating of one out of five stars, though this comes from only 10 reviews. The company averages about one complaint per month on the BBB website and has responded in the past, showing it follows such issues.

Here’s a look at some pros and cons specific to Insure.com.

How does Insure.com work?

Insure.com saves you some trouble by letting you skip the drawn-out sign-up process. Instead, you can answer a few simple questions right on the homepage, then press “Start Now” to gain access to more information about insurance coverage.

Then, it’s time to answer a few more questions about your background so the site is better able to provide accurate quotes on insurance rates. For instance, Insure.com needs to know if it’s your first time buying car insurance, as that may affect your rates.

Once you’ve made it to the end of Insure.com’s questionnaire, you’ll have access to your free quotes. But keep in mind, these aren’t real-time quotes that were generated just for you. Instead, Insure.com will redirect you to some insurance companies’ sites, where you can further explore coverage options and access pricing information.

With this information in your back pocket, the folks at Insure.com hope you’re ready to reach out to an insurance agent and find a policy that works for your needs and budget.

Insure.com reviews: Here’s what customers are saying

Does it seem like customers enjoy their experiences with Insure.com? Does it help them find the right deal?

On Clearsurance, a website that helps people compare different insurance websites, several Insure.com users have weighed in with their experiences. The user below had a pretty positive experience with Insure.com. They might not have found the lowest prices after using the site, but they found a good deal.

Meanwhile, the following user was disappointed with their Insure.com experience. They didn’t have much luck finding a good deal, and then they were left with countless calls from car insurance companies.

This was a common criticism of Insure.com. While there isn’t a disclaimer on the website that says it shares your information with third parties, you should be aware that you might get a barrage of calls and emails if you enter your information on Insure.com.

One customer on Trustpilot had a similar experience.

In general, Clearsurance’s customer satisfaction ratings paint a mixed picture of the Insure.com user experience.

As for financial strength, Insure.com has an A++ rating from AM Best and an AAA rating from Moody’s, indicating excellent financial strength.

Insure.com vs. Insurify

In general, Insurify and Insure.com have a similar user experience. Both skip the lengthy sign-up process and let you start answering their questionnaires in a matter of seconds. The questionnaires on both sites cover similar details and can be completed in a matter of minutes.

From there, things diverge. With Insurify, you’ll gain access to real-time quotes personalized to your exact needs and specifications. Meanwhile, Insure.com will direct you to the websites of auto insurance companies, home insurance companies, or life insurance companies, depending on your needs. Your information will be shared with these insurance companies, while Insurify won’t do that.

Insure.com vs. Gabi

Gabi wants you to stop overpaying for car insurance by making it easy to compare quotes. While the site flow of Gabi is similar to Insure.com — both sites have you answer questions then deliver results — Gabi delivers real quotes in real time. This means Gabi’s quotes are a bit more personalized and will probably lead to a few spam calls after you use the site.

For real quotes in real time and no spam calls after the fact, you’ll want to give Insurify a try. Whether you’re looking to work with a major insurer like GEICO or USAA or a smaller regional chain, Insurify has the proprietary data needed to connect you with great deals.

Is Insure.com a spammy site?

User experiences captured in reviews show customers have received phone calls, texts, and emails after entering their information into Insure.com. The exact number of contacts varies, but some customer reviews say they received hundreds of messages.

Others report not receiving such communications after selecting the option to opt out and prevent Insure.com from selling their private information.

In all, 68% of respondents reported a positive user experience using Insure.com, according to Clearsurance’s report. For users considering entering information into Insure.com, it means you should take the time to understand what could happen and select the opt-out option if you don’t want further communication.